Analogies, analogy-conclusions and the feelings of the horse
Analogien, Analogie-Schlüsse und die Befindlichkeiten des Pferdes
Meyer H
DOI: 10.21836/PEM20140308
Year: 2014
Volume: 30
Issue: 3
Pages: 310-334
Analogy-conclusions considerably support the explanations of the behaviour and the psychic experiences of men and animals in both prescientific interpretations and in scientific processes of cognition. Based on the known qualities of one species, we find out the existence of corresponding qualities of another species, similar to the field examined, by these analogy-conclusions. Differing from the impression given by the notion “conclusion”, the corresponding qualities are mostly not found in rational discursive processes. As a rule, we are spontaneously convinced of these qualities while observing the behaviour of men and animals. In that way, the analogy-conclusions produced lead to judgements, which are experienced as sure and evident. A science which is based on empirism and rationality does not trust in immediate sureties. It asks for detailed descriptions and rational analyses of the generally accessible behaviour. In particular, it asks for the critical investigation of the facts which point, validly and reliably, to psychic experiences. Especially to go against widespread practice, to propose that animals in general, and horses in particular, have defined intentions, looks to empirical-rational science as an explanation which does not require such assumptions.The facts suggest interpreting the psychic experiences as evolutionary achievements, which, as a rule, further the chances of survival. Therefore, the psychic experiences, in the first place, are differentiated dichotomously: when pleasant, they are beneficial for maintaining the existing life and circumstances; when unpleasant, they promote changes of life and/or of circumstances. Among the different species, the psychic experiences are at different stages of differentiation. Moreover, the different psychic experiences among the different species seem to have a different significance regarding way in which to survive. These results of evolutionary processes contribute to the limitations of analogy-conclusions. They do so strongly connected with the different physiological abilities to receive and to work on stimuli. By insisting on the orientation on generally accessible facts and on their generally obligatory rational analysis, science often denies the generally obligatory legitimation of spontaneous convictions, as well as the generally obligatory legitimation of analogy-conclusions based on estimated similarities and of judgements based on empathic feelings. Science, which is exclusively obliged to cognition, does that without giving directions, which allows one to act efficiently as a result of the affective and the emotional commitment to animal welfare. The terms feeling, emotion, psychic state, psychic process, and psychic experience are here used, to a great extent, synonymously.
