The intelligence of the horse – a bio-logical analysis against the background of controversial opinions

The intelligence of the horse – a bio-logical analysis against the background of controversial opinions

Zur Intelligenz des Pferdes – die bio-logische Analyse vor dem Hintergrund kontroverser Meinungen

Meyer H

DOI: 10.21836/PEM20080607
Year: 2008
Volume: 24
Issue: 6
Pages: 792-830

Not only literary men but also persons, which are dealing professionally with horses, assume intellectual abilities of the horse. They concede, that these abilities are not apparent by the first view, but can be detected by investigations with deeper knowledge of the horse. Opposite to that other laymen and other horsemen express their low estimation about the intelligence of the horse. The defenders of both positions refer to present observations and to testimonials from different epoches and cultures; some give informations about extraordinary emotional and mental performances of the horse, others about an animal, which is missing thinking and mental understanding. Against such frequent ideologicaly directed positions the following argumentation will be bio-logical: The horse survived not by mental understanding and not by reflections; still it does not do so. During the evolution abilities of that kind would not have given to the horse selective benefits. Therefore such abilities did not develop. Eating grass, the perception of enemies and the flight from them did not challenge the horse in an intellectual way. The “Biogramm” of the horse demanded other abilities. These the horse evolved in a range, that it was ableand is still able to survive in enviroments with different resources and different risks. It is possible, to demonstrate the “biogramm” of the horse as an example, that intelligence is not an unrenounceable biological ability. The analysis of the “Biogramm” of the horse, which is explicated here, has the same result as a lot of experiments dealing with the intellgence of the horse: The ability, to understand causal and final connections, to find conclusions corresponding with such an understanding and to make dicisions between alternative ways of behaviour based on mental understanding, could not be demonstrated in horses, if the interpretation of the investigations is critical. This result was sometimes inconsistent with the expectation and the interpretation of the organizers of the experiments. The biological understanding of intelligence shows, that the effort to upgrade the horses intellectual abilities appear as an alien request, because of being inspired by the autistic view of humans as animals, which are surviving by their intelligence in enviroments with different resources and different dangers and which are arranging by their intelligence their life in cultural view.

Nach oben scrollen